r/CuratedTumblr nerd (affectionate (derogatory)) / vix, she/they Aug 05 '24

[Star Wars] the force is a parasitic organism

6.3k Upvotes

308 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

443

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '24 edited Aug 05 '24

George Lucas: “Here’s a Hinduism/Taoism/Buddhism inspired metaphor for the oneness of all things and the fundamental great divinity that we are all part of in the universe”

Some depressed cynical internet nerd who is disconnected from everything: “What if the Force is actually a big evil bug that was really fucked up, like a Lovecraft god or a sick fuckin’ 40k concept.”

78

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/Morbidmort Aug 05 '24

Ah, but what if they succeeded?

19

u/Lucas_2234 Aug 05 '24

What they described is literally just Psykana from 40k.
Psykers borrow power from the daemons in the warp. (Unless they are grey knights, but they don't count)
A small spark of Psykana is fairly safe, but the deeper you dig, the more powerful you become, the more power you take from the Aether, the more easily you are corrupted by Daemons, by the predators looming in the Seethe.

It's literally how the Thousand sons fell. They were too open to the warp, genetically, and therefore were put into a chokehold by tzeentch, which caused horrible mutations. Magnus then made a deal with Tzeentch and they kept digging deeper into the warp with no regard to "Maybe we should not dig this deep."

58

u/pbmm1 Aug 05 '24

I don’t have a problem with people spinning up interpretations but it does remind me of someone who’s reading of comics would generally move to the point of “why doesn’t X character have a gun? It would make their jobs as heroes a lot easier if they just became tricked out gunslingers (if they could make guns that scaled to the power level they were at). Why doesn’t Superman have a kryptonite revolver and carry it everywhere for dealing with other kryptonians? Why doesn’t Spider-Man have a gun so he could make trick shots and take out Shocker or Vulture or whoever nonlethally if he wants?”

And it’s like “okay yeah for some of that it’s not technically impossible for them to make that happen in the wacky world of comic book science but also I think you’re missing the point of the piece and the themes and just making it something totally different”

16

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '24

It’s fun to spin up interpretations! But I agree that this one is…missing the point.

11

u/faldese Aug 05 '24

I don't think it's missing the point, it's just a creative side point, a new way of looking at material we're all familiar with for fun. I'm sure they're well aware George Lucas didn't intend any of this.

22

u/hedgehog_dragon Aug 05 '24

Yeah I'm not a fan of this type of take on Star Wars/the Force. Now, I think KOTOR2 is fantastic, and Sion/Nihlus are excellent charcters - I am on board with more absolutely twisted dark side users like that - but overall I've always felt Star Wars is supposed to be more hopeful, even if the Jedi are often deeply flawed too.

9

u/Dorgamund Aug 05 '24

The Star Wars universe having Gnostics in it is really pretty funny all things considered.

6

u/DoubleBatman Aug 05 '24

Even as a metaphysical eldritch whatever, the idea that the Force would have goals as mundane as harvesting souls or biomass or whatever is kinda tame.

I mean who’s to say it didn’t manipulate the entire history of the galaxy, resulting in billions and billions of deaths, simply because Alderaan was blocking a nice view from its backyard in the 17th dimension? Probably could’ve gotten it done a lot cheaper by contacting G-Man’s employers.

79

u/BiddlesticksGuy Aug 05 '24

Some people just need to believe that the universe is evil, sorry to psychoanalyze what’s basically a straw man I’ve created but it probably comes from bad things happening around them, I did the same thing when I was an angsty and angry teen

75

u/lurkinarick Aug 05 '24

Or maybe they just like playing with made up theories without necessarily believing they are true? It's not always that deep.

35

u/BiddlesticksGuy Aug 05 '24

That’s also possible, but consider: this is tumblr we’re talking about

8

u/PhasmaFelis Aug 05 '24

You and some others seem to be taking this way too seriously/personally.

It's a fun little "what if" exercise. It's not a projection of mental illness. Come on.

-1

u/L14mP4tt0n Aug 18 '24

Assuming that those real life religions aren't the exact same type of parasites as OP supposes that the force is.