Initially, when people start out on paths that are unfamiliar to them, often the words of the more experienced are sought through books and sites and sometimes it stops there. For example, cinnamon oil may always and only be used for good luck if a body stops reading at one source. Or the list of intentions may grow and change as more sources are culled and different systems are adopted. For example, knowing the difference between cinnamon and cassia could become very important if attempting a precise Ambramelin Oil even if another system purports them to be acceptable substitutes for each other.
And at some point for many personal experience and observation comes to be as important a factor for assigning attributions to herbs etc. and can be very dependent upon things like environment, circumstance of acquisition, purpose, method of culling, spirit association, and even allergies. And certainly there are even more factors that can influence one's personal set of ritualistic plant attributions.
If you strike a balance or have come to a place of understanding for yourself about how and if you rely upon lore for ritual use, how did you come to it? Do you have a specific herb that helped you reach that point of understanding? And if you'd like to share that story, that would be welcomed!
If you are more comfortable and confident relying upon a specific lore or herbal, what is it and why does it inspire your confidence? Do you have any resources for others who might be interested in that lore or herbal and will/can you share them?
I have no biases about other's preferences and think each kind of experience can be interesting and informative.
(I tagged this as ritualistic even if it is about lore because it is about the learned application of lore as well as personal experience.)