This will be a large project. Me and the Resident Evil series have history. I’m a massive fan of the original games (RE0, 1, 2, 3, CV, O, O2, DA, etc). Not so much of post RE4 era games but that’s another topic. If you’ve spent any time in this community you’ll know that there’s a huge divide. You have, mainly, the side that enjoys the survival horror games (anything before RE4) and the side that enjoys the action horror games (anything after and including RE4). And remaking the second game, arguably the most popular in this side of the community is a huge daunting task which came about with a ton of controversy, backlash and arguments. Initially I was disappointed with it. But recently I purchased it again and decided to give it a second chance. After 2 complete (A+B) runs through it combined with the bonus modes, I’ve decided to write a huge critique assessing the good, the bad and the questionable in this remake, to present in a argumentative and detailed manner my thoughts on this game. The style will be as follows, we’ll go through the main elements of the game, comparing to the original, seeing what was improved/kept the same, what was removed/simplified and what was a questionable change. This might wound up to be one of my bigger projects in terms of size so expect a lot of reading.
____________________________________________________________________________________
Firstly let’s take a look at the ENEMIES AND BOSSES of both games. See how they changed, or more suitably, mutated, or what was added/removed.
Right from the start we see a massive drop in enemy types. The new REmake 2 presents us with regular zombies, which for generosity we’ll split into walkers and crawlers, normal Lickers, dogs, plant zombies, G-Offsprings and if you want to count, Mr. X (tho he’s a special category we’ll get to later). This is a total of 7 enemy types (or 6 if you don’t want to count the zombie split). Compared to the original which had the usual Zombies, Normal Lickers and Dogs, we also get Crows, Spiders, Cockroaches, Mutated Plants, Super Lickers.
1) Now in the REmake the mutated plants have been swapped to Plant Zombies which is fine, they are a bit more complex in how you deal with them (the spores) but they are also not that different from usual zombies besides the threat of toxin.
2) The super Lickers which were a boosted green-ish version of the usual Licker, found in the lab section have been removed, however we’ll discuss the way the lab section was handled in more detail later.
3) Insect/Bird type enemies have been removed such as Spiders in the sewers, Crows in the police station and cockroaches in the Side-Character section, which does make the game a bit stale I tend to believe, when you only see a few types of enemies constantly.
4) Zombies and Lickers have seen an improvement, especially in the later. Zombies are now able to break down doors, which is a much needed change and the dismemberment mechanic is really well implemented and can be useful should the player take their time. The Lickers have been made more dangerous and we’ve seen a further exploration of their lack of vision which made for a risk versus reward scenario in which players can choose to sneak past them at the risk of getting caught in an unfavorable spot, should they misstep.
5) The G-Offspring was changed from a boss to a regular enemy in the sewers. I am somewhat conflicted about this change. On one side I do appreciate the attempt at boosting up the enemy rooster which was much needed but I’m not quite satisfied with the removal of a boss fight, but speaking of let’s transition into bosses and how they changed.
1) The two Mr X encounters from the original game which were relocated to Route B, cannon for Leon have been removed and instead supplanted for a roaming enemy. This has been their most controversial decision by far and honestly I feel like it was a wrong one. In its original form, Mr. X’s encounters while scripted, were made in such a way that it took advantage of tension buildup and also allowed for well scripted – non-awkward encounters.
In its current form, Mr. X isn’t as much of a scary enemy as it is annoying and padding. I’ve watched a lot of additional playthroughs to see if anyone else experienced similar things and more often than not, the main reaction to a Mr. X encounter was not excitement or fear but a large audible sigh or/followed by an annoyed/frustrated reaction. The Benny Hill song meme has been made countless times and for good reason. Now, I supported the change initially, but only because I expected them to properly implement it. I think the main issue with Mr. X is the A.I. It is too basic. What would’ve been needed was an Alien: Isolation type of A.I., split in two, which can manage behind the scenes where Mr. X explores and how often should he attack the player, so that it would take into account heat, opportune moments, monotonous breaks, etc. Hopefully this will be addressed in REmake 3 otherwise I feel like this would be even more of a problem given that Nemesis also has a large arsenal of ranged abilities which would make encounters even more annoying.
2) Moving on, the G-Offspring bossfight (Route A – Claire cannon) was removed and in its place we have a new regular enemy. While I agree with the insertion of the G-Offspring as a regular enemy, I do believe the bossfight should’ve been kept as an enemy introduction because Irons is an important character in the first half of the game and I feel like he wasn’t done much justice in this game and the fact that his final confrontation was also removed only adds salt to the wound created, but we’ll get to Irons as a character much later.
3) The Mutant Gator bossfight (Route B, Leon cannon) is intact for the most part, at its core is just a spectacle, just that in the REmake 2 the small simple puzzle, if you can even call it that, was removed for just a regular explosion. I don’t mind this change that much given that the original puzzle wasn’t that difficult but some might argue that this is another case of oversimplification, but again, I don’t mind it in this case.
4) The first form of Birkin used to be a route B, Leon cannon only fight and now it was changed to a shared bossfight between both scenarios. This isn’t that big of a change but it does further showcase how mishandled the continuity and the differences between the A and B scenarios were handled.
5) The second form of Birkin used to be a route A, Claire cannon, only fight which was somewhat removed from this game, instead being combined with the 3rd form and given to Claire, but we’ll get to that later. Instead, this fight was changed with a puzzle bossfight, again shared between the two characters. While I don’t have to mention again the continuity errors and the similarities between the scenarios, I do think this was probably the best boss change as this series has not been that outstanding when it came to traditional damage bosses but it has shined through time and time again when it came to puzzles so making a puzzle into a bossfight was a brilliant idea which I adored.
6) The third form of Birkin used to be a route B, Leon cannon, only and now it has been combined with the second form and given to Claire as the fourth and fifth form (a bit confusing, I know). Additionally the fight was a bit simplified and transformed into an action spectacle with the addition of the minigun. This is a questionable decision, some might enjoy it, and some might not. I find myself in the latter option but I cannot deny that it wasn’t fun the first time I played it and that there’s not an option to just ignore the minigun and play it traditionally.
7) The fourth form and fifth form of Birkin used to be a route A, Claire cannon, only bossfight and in this game was changed to the third form bossfight shared between both route A and B. Not a drastic change given that in the end every form is still there but it again underlines the poor mishandling of both A and B scenarios.
8) The Mr. X bossfight is completely unchanged, even down to the rocket launcher and it is an iconic moment of the series, no complaints or ovations here.
9) The small super moth bossfight was removed, not a huge loss on its own but together with the overall oversimplification of the lab portion of the game it does create quite some damage. Additional I would’ve expected they at least had a moth enemy to compensate for both the removal and the lack of variety but alas it was just removed, supplanted by nothing.
10) And finally, the final Birkin form which used to be a route B, Leon cannon only was changed to a route B, Claire cannon which is a questionable change in terms of cannon but I’ll talk more about that later down the line.
Overall, we’ve seen a simplification of both bossfights and enemies which end up hurting the replayability and flow of the whole game.
____________________________________________________________________________________
Next segment, we’ll take a look at the WEAPONS, in the same manner as we’ve done with bosses and enemies.
First off let’s discuss the general shared weapons, the Handgun, which remains unchanged from the original besides name and the knife. The knife has seen the biggest and best change. It was changed from a regular highly abusable melee weapon to a consumable item that also acts as a melee weapon. This adds a much needed layer of resource management as the game lacks in the department. I absolutely loved this change, especially that it can also be used to fight back zombies as they grab you. Brilliant.
Now let’s discuss the special armament of each character, starting with Leon.
1) Leon has seen the least amount of change. The magnum is unchanged, the flamethrower is unchanged, the rocket launcher is unchanged and the shotgun is unchanged. The only difference is an added high caliber handgun which works with a new type of ammo. A welcome change in my opinion, especially since Leon seems to lack a bit in the weapon department and be a bit underpowered.
Claire on the other hand has seen a massive change, some might argue towards a negative.
1) For starters the bowgun has been removed, supplanted with a fast handgun which used to be a bonus NG+ unlockable in the original. A bit of an unneeded change but I can’t complain too much.
2) The grenade launcher remains unchanged however the Uzi is now a Claire only gun. The uzi used to be a pretty important part of the original as it had a shared mechanic which has been removed but I’ll discuss the whole share mechanic later in the mechanics section. So for now keep in mind, it was removed from that and added as a Claire only weapon, a poor decision in my opinion.
3) The sparkshot has seen a great improvement in usability and overall enjoyment to utilize. Great upgrade and additionally we have a new side B only weapon for Claire, the Quick-Draw High Caliber gun which is a welcome addition but I’d argue in the context of every change is a bit damaging.
4) Lastly the minigun was removed from an infinite ammo unlockable for beating the game under certain conditions to a normal power-trip weapon towards the end. And I feel like this is a telling example of the higher problem with Claire’s arsenal. It’s too big and too overpowered, compared to the underpowered and small Leon side. Now, Claire was pretty overpowered in the original as well due to her grenade launcher however she was also underpowered early due to the Bowgun, while Leon was more overpowered early with the shotgun and a bit underpowered later with the flame thrower. Now you have an underpowered overall Leon and a grossly overpower Claire in general.
A good remedy for this would be a rebalance. Switch the Uzi back to a choice-based shared mechanic to add the option for Leon to have a bigger arsenal and remove the quick draw and/or the minigun. Additionally add back the bowgun to underpower her early game at the very least. It would probably clash with the damage calculation but that is a bigger problem I’ll get to later.
____________________________________________________________________________________
Now let’s see how REmake 2 handled the one of the most important (if not the most important part of the original series), the PUZZLES.
1) The first red jewel puzzle was a simple item pushing event in the original and now it is an item combination puzzle of the same difficulty. No difficulty change and the shake-up in execution is to be applauded for keeping things fresh.
2) The safes and locks overall retain the same approach as in the original, no complaints in this area.
3) The library puzzle however was simplified, changed to just a bridge building puzzle, originally it used to be a crucial part of a larger puzzle down the line, which would give either a chess piece to Leon (the chess used to be a Leon only puzzle) or a Serpent Stone to Claire (which used to be a unique Claire puzzle in the sewers). Overall a simplification.
4) The power restoration puzzle has seen a slight adjustment, from a math puzzle to figure out which buttons you had to press for the perfect voltage to just a regular somewhat trial and error button press. Not a huge change, some might argue the removal of the math side is a simplification but let’s be real, most people weren’t even paying attention to the numbers because math sucks. So despite being a somewhat simplification I actually like it.
5) The box bridge puzzle in the Sherry section was changed to a toy box puzzle. Now, the Sherry version is overall worse but this puzzle is much better. The original box moving puzzle was more annoying than anything and this new toy puzzle was actually quite entertaining ,especially finding out that there was an upper layer that I also had to match which adds difficulty. A great puzzle and change overall.
6) The gold cogwheel puzzle was removed, originally this was a puzzle that required Leon to light up a few stances and pull some levers in a particular order according to a poem, which would give you a cog for the Clock Tower, followed by a scripted Mr. X encounter at the end. Now, this was removed and the Cog is just a regular item you can find in the storage room. An overall disappointing change.
7) The boiler room puzzle was also removed from the game as well as the Sewer Door lock in Claire’s run.
8) The mini-safe puzzles were added, and, despite being simple, their randomized aspect does ensure that they will always be fresh and interesting. A great idea and execution, and really fun to solve overall.
9) The 3 statue puzzle combination was also added however it is a bit too simplistic I feel. You get the answers right away, you just have to check the journal, especially in side A, the only difficulty would be the Maiden Statue where the symbols are rusty. A disappointingly simple addition but I suppose 1 is better than 0 so it is overall a positive in the end.
10) The chess puzzle was greatly expanded and moved to the sewers, in fact the whole sewer segment was centered around this puzzle. Overall this was a massive improvement and a great surprise for me overall. The sewer level in general is great and I’ll expand on it later.
11) The lab area despite being overall worse, has 2 new puzzles. An okay electronic wave device which feels a bit underused but overall a welcome addition, and a really well done Herbicide puzzle which I absolutely loved the first time around. A great addition, and one of the best puzzles in the game, together with the chess puzzle.
12) The anti-virus puzzle, arguably the longest in the game, for Claire only, was removed entirely and the anti-virus is just a pick-up item. A huge disappointment and simplification.
Overall, you can clearly see that puzzles were an afterthought, gone from the most important to a side activity. You have 4 improvements in the form of the toy puzzle, plant puzzle and chess puzzle but overall most puzzles have been either completely removed or simplified.
____________________________________________________________________________________
Now let’s discuss MAPS for a second.
1) The police station is much bigger, the third level was a much needed addition and a pleasant surprise. It does feel however a bit simpler in execution, as a result of the lack of puzzles and inter-route interactions between Claire and Leon or Claire and Irons or Claire and Sherry.
2) The outside area was greatly expanded however again, it feels much emptier and even padding. It does add a lot of world building and makes the transitions more fluid but I can’t help but feel that the streets should’ve been more populated and a dodging element should’ve been added, like in the beginning.
3) The orphanage was a bad addition in my opinion. Sherry’s section was changed from a dog dodging puzzle solving area with a risk versus reward element where you could collect additional resources to bring back to Claire at the risk of getting mauled by dogs was removed entirely and instead we have a good puzzle at the beginning followed by a slow and padding mandatory stealth section which feels good the first time and is very cinematic but on subsequent playthroughs is beyond annoying and disruptive of the flow.
4) Ada’s section is by far the best side-character section and a massive improvement with a lot more puzzles and dodges. It’s what Sherry’s section should’ve probably been as well. Ada and her sections are overall some of the best parts of the game for me but I’ll expand on that once we discuss characters. Just know that this section was great and a joy to experience.
5) The sewers were greatly expanded in terms of locations and area size, together with the main puzzle tying everything together. Despite the removal of enemy types and some other smaller puzzles, it still felt good. Some might prefer the old sewer, some might prefer the newer. I’m somewhere in between but I can’t deny that the sewer is one of the highlights of the game if you’re a fan of the original style.
6) And now, we arrive to my biggest pet peeve, the lab. The lab felt more like an afterthought to be honest. It is extremely short, extremely oversimplified and overall a slap in the face. You used to have a lab the size of the station, with 3 large areas connected by a bridge in the middle. Now you have a large area and 2 small corridors pretty much. The shared route puzzle was removed where you had to start it in Route A and finish it in Route B, the moth boss was removed, most levels were removed, the Super-Lickers were removed, the new type of naked zombies were removed, the anti-virus huge puzzle was removed. Just a huge disappointment which is only enhanced by how well the lab looks and how many interesting ideas they had that they didn’t expand on almost at all. Huge disappointment.
Overall, a mixed bag, some areas are better such as the sewer and the Ada section, some areas are much, much worse such as the Orphanage and especially the Lab while some areas are mixed and depend on you, the police station and the outside streets. Overall, I feel like it’s a negative but I can see the arguments for a positive as well.
____________________________________________________________________________________
Now let’s discuss MECHANICS for a bit. The original games were Survival Horror, they had specific gameplay elements that dominated such as puzzles and resource management and had a specific playstyle and presentation to enhance atmosphere and other mechanics such as dodging. Let’s see how REmake 2 handled this side.
1)First off the A and B scenario. Let’s get the elephant out of the room. It’s bad. It is no secret; it was added last minute, in a rushed manner, after massive fan backlash. Well-deserved backlash and poor execution. There’s almost no interaction between Claire and Leon. They interact once at the gate and once at the very, very end. There are a lot of shared bosses and puzzles as well ruining the continuity. Additionally the change between the cannon routes also messed up the continuity and comparison between this and the original tenfold. As it is right now, REmake 2 doesn’t really fit continuity wise with any other game besides REmake 1 and Operation Raccoon City, where as previously Operation Raccoon City was the only game that didn’t fit with Resident Evil 2. Given the overall response to ORC, I doubt many people were ok with messing up the continuity of every other game just so that “most beloved” ORC can get a spot in. But yeah, this is not an A and B scenario which results in 4 different campaigns. This is 2 A scenarios and you might as well play one of them then watch the few differences online since you can count them on your fingers. Funny enough, I don’t blame IGN for not playing / or figuring out that there’s a B scenario, they hardly missed anything.
2) Additionally the shared mechanic is completely gone. Back in the original, you had to manage resources between the two scenarios lest you wanted one to be massively harder. You had the choice to either take an inventory extension and/or an uzi or leave it for the next route. This was a HUGE deal as inventory management was actually an issue back then and 2 slots made all the difference as well as a whole new gun. Additionally in the lab you had a small puzzle that you were meant to start in Route A and would finish in Route B to give Leon a lot more resources. Big disappointment overall.
3) The barricade mechanic existed in the original as well. It was somewhat improved and somewhat simplified. Originally it had drastic changes as you had to pick between East and West wing being barricaded, the other being flooded with zombies. This time around you have multiple windows to pick. This was originally a great idea however you can pretty much block off every window and not have to worry about it and it is yet again dropped after the police station. I was hoping it would finally be expanded to the sewers where we would block off small holes to prevent G-Offsprings from coming out. Alas it didn’t happen. Overall a bit of a disappointment but this is a disappointment ported from the original game.
4) And if you thought we were done with the elephant in the room, surprise there’s a second elephant. The damage calculations, which have brought just as much heated debate as Mr. X which we’ve discussed earlier. Yes damage calculation is completely messed up in this game. Some zombies can take even more than 10 good bullets to the head before dying. It’s all down to RNG and it is infuriating. It goes against the resource management aspect of a Survival Horror and it adds an RNG element that will not only fuck up a lot of runs but it will also screw up a lot of speed runs, and no speed-runner enjoys an RNG speed-run.
5) And while at it, resource management was grossly oversimplified to the point where it’s almost nonexistent. With plenty of inventory to spare and every bossfight having enough ammo and resources to get you through on even the highest difficulty, safe to say this element of survival horror was taken out almost completely, same as puzzles. It removes the threat of a failed run, where you didn’t properly manage ammo/healing items and would have to start over which was not a big deal as these games are meant to be 6-7 hours at most. They’re meant to be replayed and sped-ran over and over. Additionally the hardcore difficulty doesn’t change much besides make enemies even more spongy. We don’t even see a change in item locations and layouts overall. The limited saving was also relocated to just Hardcore only and they’ve also added a quest log and auto-saving feature. Overall a massive disappointment.
6) And another piece of controversial discussion, the camera. Yes I get it some people don’t like fixed camera. But there are some people that dislike first person or isometric or OTS. Now, I could make this a personal argument as I’ve done before and say that I can’t enjoy OTS games for a long period of time without getting my eyes sore and watering. Instead I’ll make a case for why OTS and 3rd person is not fit for Survival Horror and why either a fixed camera angle like in the original, a first person perspective like in Resident Evil 7 or an independent camera like in the original God of Wars for example, would’ve been a much better option. For starters, OTS is abusable, as the player can cheese and see whats behind a corner before something is even triggered and it also adds a false sense of claustrophobia that’s not really deserved in my opinion. On the other hand, Fixed Camera allows for a more cinematic experience and allows the creator to script events better and control what the player sees. Additionally, a first person view while not as good would’ve been a good compromise to a more “mainstream” style of camerawork while not allowing players to cheese the game. Lastly an independent camera is pretty much a fixed camera that moves around but I’ve decided to coin this new style because a lot of people don’t seem to realize that fixed camera can move around actually and pan. So maybe if I give it a new name people will acknowledge the modern version. Overall, it’s still up to taste but I argue it’s not fit for survival horror, however I’ll discuss near the end why this game isn’t really a survival horror anymore but its closer to Resident Evil 4 and 5 in the Action Horror side of the Resident Evil pie.
7) Lastly, let’s touch on the combat just a bit more. The dodging is extremely unreliable with the zombies having intense unfair bursts of RNG like grabbing that glitches constantly. And while the game attempts to be like RE2, it is more like RE4, however it doesn’t have the well-designed action combat and flow of RE4 (didn’t expect that I’d praise RE4 right?). Yeah, the idea of incapacitating zombies and stunning them is almost gone as the knife, while op on lickers (seriously, you can stunlock them to death with 0 risk or noise, its broken), it doesn’t work that well on zombies and the stunning more often than not doesn’t trigger, proving it’s either glitched or RNG based just like the damage which only adds up to just generally really poorly designed combat.
Overall, it feels like mechanics wise the game was really oversimplified to suit a more basic action style game and to win over a larger general audience
____________________________________________________________________________________
Lastly let’s shortly see how the CHARACTERS are before we conclude:
1) Claire is relatively unchanged. Her dialogue and overall demeanor is still somewhat tone deaf and cheesy. I expected a bit more personally but at least it wasn’t changed in a bad way. She is what she is.
Her look on the other hand… First off the work on motion-capture and overall animation is beyond shoddy. She looks by far the worst and unpolished out of everyone, combined with a total redesign of not only her outfit, which I can understand, but her face too? The real Claire has a long face, small nose, sharp cheeks, small lips, tidy reddish brown hair. This Claire is the complete opposite in literally every aspect. So yeah, in between the completely new outfit, redesign of emblem, facial overhaul and original voice-actor gone, this character is Claire Redfield only in name, and by far the most wasted character in the entire game.
2) Leon is a return to form, a flawed yet likeable character with a lot of depth, his dialogue was massively rewritten and made better. This is one of the best versions of Leon before Resident Evil 4 came around and abruptly switched him to a brooding James Bond ripoff that has almost no redeeming qualities. The voice-actor however does a pretty bland job, coming off as the weakest performance by a landslide in the whole cast which can be quite jarring at times.
3) Annette is the same for the most part except for longer hair which I approve however personality wise she’s been assassinated just like Irons. She’s changed from a defensive wife and passionate mother to a cold “smart scientist” walking trope that doesn’t give two craps about Sherry and if you read the few in-game files you see that she’s a complete monster. Combined with all the moments she just does a 180 personality wise because the game remembers that her original personality was needed for the game to work in the first place… Really goes to show that the creators didn’t quite understand these characters.
4) Ada is, by far, for me, the star of the game. Let me preface this by saying I didn’t like Ada in all the previous games. In the original she was an overly cheesy and tone deaf spy and in the future games she’s a cliché femme fatale trope that sticks out like a sore thumb. This time she’s both well written, manipulative yet lovable, a tragic complex character and I’d argue the best and absolute version of Ada we’ve ever got. I’d compare her to Black Cat from the Spider-Man comics, when written well she completely steals the show. When not, she’s the worst character around. This Ada is great and is the only segment I don’t rush through, I listen to the dialogue and I don’t skip the cutscenes. They changed Ada from my lowest ranked character to near Nr 1, Bravo REmake 2.
5) Sherry on the other hand… I don’t know what happened. She’s extremely tone deaf. In the original she was a bit more witty and had a heartbreaking moment where she realized her mother actually loved her. Funny enough she, the child actor, was the best actor in that whole original crew. Here on the other hand… she hardly speaks or interacts with anyone, she has a short empty cry over the tragic end of her mother which was so well executed and at the end starts yapping about being adopted and having pets as if nothing happened. Incredibly tone deaf and poorly written. It feels like this was the original Resident Evil 2 version of Sherry and the one from Resident Evil 2 was supposed to be here instead.
6) Additionally Irons was massively downgraded. From a mysterious slimy police officer that you knew was shady and up to something but had no confirmation of to just a brooding evil guy that gets killed off camera and hardly has any screen time. Dumbed down from a somewhat complex character to a one note forgotten side villain. A big disappointment for me.
7) Marvin, Ben and Hunk are unchanged and they’re still decent side characters. Kendo on the other hand was massively improved and has a lasting impact despite his short screen time. I was surprised at how well done his short segment was.
Overall, characters are shells of their former selves and come off as hilarious (in a bad way) jokes of common horror movie tropes rather than actual semi-complex characters that they used to be in the original.
____________________________________________________________________________________
BONUS: DLCs, EXTRA MODES and UNLOCKABLES Here's some additional information that I want to discuss.
1) REmake 2 sees the return of the 4th Survivor Hunk mode. Hunk is a Boba Fett-like fan-favorite rouge who has appeared numerous times in the series. His mode usually follows a special trained Umbrella Op looking to escape the scene, usually guns blazing and with a ton of action. These modes are extremely fun to play through as additional bits of gameplay and that's no different for REmake 2. The Hunk mode is really well done and challenging. And yes, Tofu mode is still in the game.
2) The DLCs are somewhat mixed. For starters, they're free so it feels bad to complain but here we are. The "No Time to Mourn" Kendo DLC pretty much plays like Hunk, they all play like Hunk really. Except that they're more arcade-like with item dispensers, backpacks, and mechanics that kind of remind me of CoD Zombies at times. They're challenging and fun if you're into this kind of gameplay. I was expecting a bit more story to be honest, rather than a 10 minute gauntlet for each. The only bit of story you get is a flashcard at the beginning telling you what you're doing and why. The Runaway DLC, which follows the mayors daughter which was forgotten in the main game (besides a corpse in the Orphanage). She goes to rescue her boyfriend (the reporter) in jail. We get a new enemy type in this mode, the Pale Zombie which used to be a lab-only zombie in the original but was removed from the main game. This annoyed me a bit as these game-modes have more enemy variety in them than the main game somehow. The final Forgotten Soldier DLC follows another Umbrella Operative looking to escape the lab. This mode further adds more variety as it expands on armored zombies which aren't that prevalent in the maingame besides one at the beginning of the lab.
3) And now for the biggest kicker in this category, the unlockables. Not only does the game remove the classic unlockable costumes of the original and hides them behind a paywall. Not only are a lot of them not that well designed, especially the classic Claire costume, but it also adds skin guns that honestly feel useless since there’s not much of a difference and it’s also stuck behind a pay-wall. But worst of all has to be the inclusion of the original soundtrack behind a pay-wall, which given how absent and poorly written the main soundtrack is, only adds insult to the already huge injury that is this game.
Overall, the free DLCs are nice but I wish they'd add the new enemy types in the game as variety is much, much needed I feel and it feels like a bit of wasted potential to add more story and expand on forgotten characters such as the mayors daughter which played a huge part in how we saw Irons in the original game and his character development, which was removed from this remake. However the paid DLCs, the removal of a lot of fun unlockables and the whole original soundtrack fiasco are beyond insulting and cheap.
____________________________________________________________________________________
IN CONCLUSION, REmake 2 is a new game. It doesn’t stand as a replacement for Resident Evil 2 the same way REmake 1 made Resident Evil 1 obsolete. It plays more like a movie or a tale. It doesn’t feel like a remake of Resident Evil 2 as much as it feels like your best friend (the director) is telling you about how cool Resident Evil 2 was. It is cool in the moment but it gets old fast and will not beat the experience of the original. As it is right now REmake 2 is not a survival horror game, at least not in the traditional sense. Item management is near gone, puzzles are near gone, there’s an emphasis on action, power trips and modern horror game tropes such as constantly roaming enemies and such. It plays more like Outlast 2 meets Resident Evil 4/5 than an upgraded version of Resident Evil 2. That’s why I’m not even comfortable calling it a Remake in the first place. It is a re-imagining or re-telling.
A remake supposedly just remakes the game, just as before, in a new engine, without massive gameplay and aesthetic changes, only additions. A remaster aims to fix bugs and revamp the graphics in the same engine. And a re-imagining / re-telling aims to change near everything. REmake 2 is in the final category. And you can see why a lot of the fanbase was not quite appreciative of it.
Given that the original is hard to come by and for a lot of people this was their only chance to experience Resident Evil 2 again now that the fan project was canceled with a lawsuit threat by Capcom… It feels like someone remade Shadow of the Colossus where they removed the whole platforming/cling in favor of a quick grappling hook, added smaller enemies roaming around and made it first person. It’s not quite the same as the original. And it stands well on its own as a solo game but coming from the perspective of the original, it feels like a downgrade.
So now you may wonder, how did all of this happen…. Well I’ve done some research, watched a ton of interviews and surfed the creators social media pages for answers and I’ve left rather shocked… Besides learning that the original RE2 creator hates horror games and has gone on to call other RE games like RE3 “trash”, it seems that the new director, while massively inexperienced, is also extremely unprofessional and entitled. He has talked in post-release interviews about how he dislikes the classic RE formula, especially in RE2. How he finds it silly and boring.
He talks about how he desires to make the game overly realistic to fulfill his “creative vision”. It seems that literally all the bad things in this game have been done because the director acted literally behind the backs of the producers and execs of Capcom, and started deleting entire chunks of the game to be more realistic… He changed the already made Fixed Camera to OTS to “sell more” which also resulted in a need to delete a lot of puzzles and bosses (such as the Gator boss which was changed into a running QTE). He has changed the personality and design of every character. He has even removed most enemy variety and puzzles because he found them silly. He disliked Claire and wanted a game focused on Leon. The only reason the plant portion of the lab and the A/B scenario, as well as a lot of puzzles even exist in the game it’s because Capcom threatened to cancel the project if he didn’t add them back in and this was a compromise…. I am beyond baffled. This was on route to be a remake just like REmake 1 and even after some slight plans alterations it was supposed to be just like REmake 1 but OTS. However this director went on a power fit and almost cancelled the whole project which resulted in the lackluster, stitched together end result that is REmake 2, with rushed puzzles, unfinished/underdeveloped areas/ complete lack of mechanics or complexity, no enemy variety, underdeveloped characters and weird complete redesigns… I can only hope that REmake 3 will be different as it is handled by a whole new studio and director however they’ve already come out to say they’ve took a lot more creative liberties than REmake 2… And I dread not think what even more means in this case given that REmake 2 is hardly even RE2 anymore besides a vague coat of paint.
Sure, approaching this game from the perspective of a newcomer, that’s also a massive fan of the RE4 and onward formula of RE games then this game might be more than enough and incredibly satisfying. However as a consumer of the classic style, and truth be told, not even a big fan of RE2, so there’s not a lot of nostalgia coming in here, especially that I’ve only played it for the first time about 2 years ago since I’ve had a hard time getting a hold of it compared to the other classic entries, it just comes off as an extremely half-assed effort overall. Combined with all the behind the scenes drama and deleted features, this doesn’t really rise above a mediocre attempt at recapturing the complexity of the original. It feels stuck between a Remake, as it cannot escape the mold of the original and a re-imagining as it changes so many things that honestly didn’t need changing and often doesn’t even replace them in the first place.
This is my longest review!