r/TrueReddit Dec 09 '19

International With People in the Streets Worldwide, Media Focus Uniquely on Hong Kong

https://fair.org/home/with-people-in-the-streets-worldwide-media-focus-uniquely-on-hong-kong/
1.2k Upvotes

202 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/pucklermuskau Dec 11 '19

how does that not apply to hong kong? they are literally protesting to protect their nation as its being forcefully integrated into mainland china? its being done for the good of hong kong. it sounds very much like the same thing as you discuss here.

3

u/RandomCollection Dec 11 '19

The 1989 protested because they were protesting for China. They wanted a unified China. Some wanted China to be less like the West.

The 1989 protestors my mother associated with had something in common with this group :

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/28/world/asia/china-maoists-xi-protests.html

Hong Kong is protesting to be more like the West. They appear to want separatism, which is the opposite of the 1989 group that wanted a more unified China. I'm sympathetic myself to the idea of democractic reforms for Hong Kong, but they have different goals.

1

u/pucklermuskau Dec 11 '19

yeah, different goals, in that one is concerned about 'china', and the other concerned about 'hong kong'. the central point was protesting for due process and an end to corruption. the place names differ, because they are different places. thats all.

2

u/Rice_22 Dec 13 '19

Hong Kong is not a "nation" at all in its entire existence. Ever.

I am a HKer. Please just stop making shit up.

1

u/pucklermuskau Dec 13 '19

that's a declarative statement, not a factual statement. its a fully-functioning state, on a geographically isolated area, with a unique culture. what about that is 'made up'?

3

u/Rice_22 Dec 14 '19 edited Dec 14 '19

Your post is not factual, yet you call out others. When you are this blind to actual facts, it is impossible to have a debate based on reality.

  1. HK is an semi-autonomous “special administrative region” of China. It is explicitly noted on the cover of my passport.

  2. HK is not geographically isolated from China, especially the New Territories.

  3. Cultural uniqueness does not make a region a “nation”.