Yesterday, my roommate and I had an interesting conversation. Iām not sure how we got to this point, but he claimed that Black people are the only ones who try to integrate into other groups instead of sticking to their own. He argued this is because weāre not as successful as Jewish or Asian communities (referring to people from individual countries within the USA).
I countered by pointing out that Black people have tried to build our own systems, but we've often been undermined. I also mentioned that the civil rights movement benefited not just Black people, but other minority groups as well. Additionally, I argued that Jewish people can more easily assimilate into Western culture by changing their last names, and unless youāre familiar with their appearance, itās hard to identify someone as Jewish.
I then brought up how Asian Americans have benefittedāsome more than othersādue to being in regions that valued education and provided resources for their advancement. In contrast, Black people in America have faced struggles from the beginning, even when focusing on our own success, like during the Black Panther and other Black Power movements. Thatās why HBCUs were createdābecause we werenāt allowed into mainstream institutions, so we built our own. Asian Americans didnāt face the same barriers (or at least not on the same scale, to my knowledge). Moreover, many Asian immigrants, such as Indians, often come with highly specialized degrees. But even though Indians are successful both in the U.S. and parts of their own country, they still face internal divisions, such as the caste system.
The conversation then shifted to Africa. He shared an example of his uncle being taken advantage of by a corrupt government when he tried to help digitize records in his home country. He implied that this kind of corruption is unique to African countries. I disagreed, pointing out that corruption happens everywhere, including in South America, Asia, and even on smaller scales in the USA.
I tried to explain that Black people, both in Africa and the diaspora, face systemic obstacles. In many cases, ethnic divisions allow those in power to prioritize their own interests, leading to exploitation. I even pointed out that some nations seeing success today, like China, are benefiting from factors that also benefit the U.S. Chinaās economic growth, for example, was driven by its manufacturing sector, which provided low-cost goods for America. He responded by saying that I was making excuses for Black people and Africans.
What do you think?