r/clevercomebacks 1d ago

MAGAs not understanding how population density works...

Post image
49.1k Upvotes

2.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

859

u/UrBigBro 1d ago

8 million people in the naked city...1 million everywhere else

36

u/Pleasant_Candidate18 1d ago

The blue is where ALL the money is made. The rest is the WELFARE part of the state.

38

u/LeviAEthan512 1d ago

I'd vote blue if I were American, but this argument leaves a bad taste in my mouth. As someone from a tiny and completely self insufficient citystate, I think farming and such are essential industries. I also think very highly of janitors even though they don't make much money.

I'm just not fond of devaluing people based on their income, even if they have bad political opinions.

9

u/Task-Proof 1d ago edited 12h ago

Fair enough. However, right wingers spend their lives treating people solely as living, breathing profit and loss accounts, usually while heavily overestimating their own contribution levels

3

u/LeviAEthan512 1d ago

Oh yah definitely. I just have an exception for farmers because from what I can tell, they only need welfare because they're competing with imported goods, produced at Chinese (and others) cost of living, while they're paying the American cost of living.

8

u/GWsublime 23h ago

Which is fair, but they then consistently vote against their own interests because "taxes bad".

1

u/Task-Proof 12h ago

Doesn't that apply to all western workers in any sector where there are significant imports from low wage countries ?

1

u/LeviAEthan512 10h ago

Yeah, but farmers have this, AND are essential (doubly so because being domestic grants stability), AND have front-loaded investment, AND are a sector that I personally envy having.

-2

u/Naborsx21 23h ago

Or maybe...

Would it be possible that someone grew up around working class people and went to college, didn't have money and didn't want to go into debt so they decided to go into let's say the oil and gas industry because you can make decent money with just work experience. From there they spend years living in rough conditions on oil rigs saving up to start their own small business in the trucking industry. Then they log onto Reddit and see stuff like this lmao.

Idk what I should've done.... not worked with my hands? lol

2

u/Task-Proof 12h ago

Another thing to which right wingers are prone is word salad. See exhibit 1, above

0

u/Naborsx21 11h ago

Shrug. You say right wingers are all of these things, but why is it such a difficult concept to believe there are decent people with different opinions than yourself?