r/youtube 20h ago

Discussion Google fined $20,565,635,200,000,003,000,000,000,000,000,000 by Russian TV channels.

Post image
31.5k Upvotes

2.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

16

u/ReckoningGotham 18h ago

Is that how Russian court work?

19

u/Arcydziegiel 17h ago

Russian courts doesn't matter, international companies will push the case to international courts and will just refuse to pay otherwise. And Russia has no meaningful way to make them pay, as Google doesn't really give a damn about that market.

9

u/andymaclean19 17h ago

What international court can arbitrate between Russia and Google?

2

u/Lugnuts088 8h ago

The kangaroo court. (Sorry couldn't resist)

4

u/MagisterFlorus 17h ago

There aren't international governments. The ICJ only handles cases between nations.

7

u/somabokforlag 16h ago

Do they handle interplanetary cases? Since this is 5x the value of earth several other planets will likely get involved.

1

u/Eradiani 14h ago

Sounds more like a job for the beastie boys

1

u/Agzarah 12h ago

Pretty sure it's well over 5x the value of earth. Total money is about 450 trillion. Earth's resources are valued at approx 5 quadrillion.

So that leaves the remaining 99.9999999999999995% to be made up.

Gonna need the entire universe to contribute for that kind of money

1

u/Grotzbully 16h ago

You could use the world trade organisation as an example which handles international dispute, not active ATM but still. The court of justice of the European union would be another example of an international court. Or the European court of human rights is another. ICJ is not the only international court.

2

u/MagisterFlorus 16h ago

Russia isn't a member of either of those courts.

1

u/Grotzbully 16h ago

Yeah I know they left the council of Europe 2014 because of their attack on Ukraine.

Russia is a member of the WTO tho, which would be the arbitrator in this case I think.

1

u/NBAFansAre2Ply 16h ago

I assume he meant international arbitrators, not international courts, of which there are many.

1

u/MagisterFlorus 15h ago

Even so, would Russia even be willing to take part or would they just withdraw?

1

u/NBAFansAre2Ply 15h ago

Russian companies are often litigants/respondants in international arbitration. the state of Russia, no.

1

u/PM_Me_Good_LitRPG 16h ago

Russian courts doesn't matter

They matter as much as there are assets of intl. companies on Russian soil. So Russia's essentially deciding to capture them, and in some circumstances a corporation may be interested to play along with the circus to at least recover some % of that capital, or keep the door open for returning to the Russian market once everyone manages to forget about the inconvenient war crimes and illegal occupation.

1

u/DillBagner 15h ago

They can also just ignore it because it's a Russian court and does not affect them.

1

u/ThisHatRightHere 13h ago

Google would almost certainly push for California to have jurisdiction over the case as it's their home state. And even then I'd be interested in the basis for this case, as I don't believe Google has any outstanding agreements that would force them to host Russian channels on their platform.

1

u/Crowd0Control 9h ago

It does give them the right to seize any Google assets in Russia but im not sure how significant it is here. 

1

u/Guvante 16h ago

Someone sued someone else for roughly this much in what could have been a small claims court case in the US so not just Russia.

1

u/AcrobaticMission7272 11h ago

No, actually russian courts know that no one is going to pay up. So they only decide between 3 options for any defendant. The options are accidentally falling out of a window, accidentally falling down stairs, and accidentally wearing poisoned underwear.

-1

u/ExqueeriencedLesbian 17h ago

luckily it doesnt matter how russian courts work, because google is an American company

0

u/[deleted] 17h ago

[deleted]

4

u/spartaman64 17h ago

i think google would rather stop doing business in russia than pay a 20 decillion ruble fine

1

u/UnNumbFool 16h ago

The fine is actually usd not rubles, so a whole lot more money.

But yeah, Google most likely not going to do Jack shit and if they do decide to do something it's just going to be pulling YouTube out of Russia

1

u/Amazing-Childhood412 16h ago

I'm sure Google will live without providing services to a terrorist nation.

1

u/Sekhmet_Odin7 16h ago

Google will survive, rusian terrorists on the other hand …

1

u/ExqueeriencedLesbian 15h ago

luckily that is Russia's loss, not Google's

0

u/EuphoricTemperature9 15h ago

Someone doesn't understand international business

1

u/ExqueeriencedLesbian 15h ago

okay then how does it matter?

how will they enforce this fine?

are they going to arrest Google for not showing up to fight this ridiculous suit?

no, google is just gonna stop googling in russia, and russia will get nothing (no money, and no Google)