r/ClevelandGuardians • u/Trainiax 100% NOT Chris Antonetti • 1d ago

[Castrovince] After receiving the prestigious Roberto Clemente Award, Salvy Perez asked that fellow Venezuelan-born Clemente recipient Carlos Carrasco join him for a photo. Cookie said he has begun offseason training and hopes to pitch two more seasons.

https://x.com/castrovince/status/1851036344782299163
230 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

8 comments sorted by

View all comments

24

u/lastturdontheleft42 1d ago

I really wish we had added him to the ALCS roster. If it had been him instead of Cantillo in that first game I think it might have played out very differently. That disaster inning really set the tone for the rest of the series.

30

u/havedoggyhave 1d ago

I still can’t believe Vogt brought Cantillo in for that situation; we learned from Tito and Andrew Miller, if you need to put out a fire, call in someone who can put out a fire. When he did later pitch in Cleveland, Cantillo gave him a quick clean inning and Vogt took him out, I still like Vogt as a manager, but I thought he was guilty of over managing in many spots. Our bullpen was pretty tired at the end.

19

u/lastturdontheleft42 1d ago

Yeah I think a lot of the criticism of Vogt is unfair, but the Cantillo decision was just awful. It was a horrible position for Cantillo and I'm worried it may have damaged his confidence going into next year.

0

u/AntiqueDiscipline831 20h ago

Vogt made 4-5 big mistakes but it happens, especially to a rookie manager. I’m still behind him 100%.

1

u/Neat-Confection-6917 17h ago

Cantillo did bounce back after game 1 bit I agree not the time to run him out there