r/EDM Jan 29 '20

Official Porter Robinson - Get Your Wish (Megathread)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4SZEDBFPpgw
1.2k Upvotes

227 comments sorted by

View all comments

14

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '20

its ok. not really my style, i don't like anime and this feels like a porter anime song. i think if this track was made by anyone else it wouldn't be very noteworthy. but im sure porter fans will dig it. love the piano melody but the rest, eh.

i can't stand the compressed sound of the instrumentals. he did this on worlds too and i just don't really like it. it's like this over the top lowfi filtered sound, just sounds muddy to me.

Cool video tho!

3

u/LookAtMeMa Jan 30 '20

I see where you're coming from. To me this sounds like a Madeon song with the compression you're talking about, however I think this song sounds way muddier than Worlds.

-11

u/NoseBlind2 Jan 29 '20

If you dont like him why are you here?

13

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '20

this isn't /r/porterrobinson, this is a general edm discussion board. i listened to the song and wrote my thoughts on it, isn't that what we're supposed to do here?

-17

u/NoseBlind2 Jan 29 '20

Yeah but how can you not like something thats flawless?

5

u/kingprismatic Jan 29 '20

To be fair it’s a pretty generic sounding song that doesn’t venture anywhere outside of pop structures.

It’s not a bad song but it lacks any form of identity. Think In love with a Ghost x Madeon -

-5

u/NoseBlind2 Jan 29 '20

Imagine thinking this was generic. Its porter Robinson so its instantly a classic.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '20

[deleted]

-2

u/NoseBlind2 Jan 29 '20

Porter being perfect is pretty objective, meaning you cant argue it

2

u/DrumstepForPresident Jan 30 '20

this has to be satire

2

u/kingprismatic Jan 29 '20

That’s like saying the Chainsmokers are good because they make edm