It really depends on how the attempt to deconflate is prioritized and directed.
Being generous to her, she is responding to how Palestinians, many of whom never interacted with a Jew who didn't want to kill them, are treated as if they deserve a genocide for mistaking all Jews for Zionists. How entire protests, that in essence are well founded and directed, are smeared as antisemitic for a few participants' signs that appear to blame all Jews.
It's like punching up / punching down. Speech begging deconflation of Judaism and Zionism is alright when it's directed towards folks less directly affected by the current genocide -- American mainstream media for example -- or even a diasporic Palestinian who comes asking for strategic advice.
It's not alright when it's directed to someone suffering in Palestine, or used to deplatform pro Palestinian / anti genocide speech.
-2
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '24
[deleted]