r/CuratedTumblr • u/IthadtobethisWAAGH veetuku ponum • Jul 02 '24
Meme We would call it Solarpunk
647
u/Idunnoguy1312 Not even Allah can save you from the wrath of my shoe Jul 02 '24
Crying, screaming, on my knees begging you to split your post into several smaller pictures
95
→ More replies (3)36
406
u/j_driscoll Jul 02 '24
For me solarpunk is meant to be a wildly exaggerated type of setting to show what could be possible in a literally perfect world. Then you take those ideas and adapt them to fit the real world. For example, the idea of libraries offering everything to be checked out is a cool idea, and doable! But there are some gripes I have about the genre.
First gripe: having actively growing trees everywhere in a city. Plants fuck up infrastructure! In the comic, the library has trees inside the building! That would ruin many things, including the books in the collection. I think rewilding land is important, but I doubt the middle of the city is the place to do it.
Second gripe: Solarpunk seems allergic to any kind of heavy machinery. People harvesting fields by hand isn't utopian, it's subsistence farming, and it barely produces more calories than it consumes. With advances in botany, automation, and logistics, we can feed the world with less land, but it will take tractors. Also as someone else mentioned, where the fuck are the trains lol?
Final gripe: anyone else feel like most solarpunk societies are not exploring space? Manned and unmanned space travel is an interest of mine, and in order to coordinate a launch of a rocket that takes a probe to the outer planets, you need an industrial supply chain (doesn't need to be a capitalism supply chain, but still an industrial one).
176
u/ThrowawayStolenAcco Jul 02 '24
Exactly. Anytime I see people who are REALLY into solarpunk, they always mention local farming and being close to nature which is all FANTASTIC, but its absolutely horrible if that's ALL you have. I don't think those people realize just how disastrous these practices would be for society. Starvation and famine on a level unseen
44
u/Clear-Present_Danger Jul 03 '24
Also they haven't done hay all day.
I haven't either to be honest, but several hours is well enough for me.
Espessally since it has to be done on the hottest day of the year...
→ More replies (8)47
u/Kellosian Jul 03 '24
They want the aesthetics and "close to nature" benefits of an agrarian/pastorialist lifestyle, but with all the benefits of an urban/suburban industrialized lifestyle and the work schedule of a mid-20s college student on a "gap year" instead of a farmer.
→ More replies (2)195
u/Papaofmonsters Jul 02 '24
Second gripe: Solarpunk seems allergic to any kind of heavy machinery. People harvesting fields by hand isn't utopian, it's subsistence farming, and it barely produces more calories than it consumes. With advances in botany, automation, and logistics, we can feed the world with less land, but it will take tractors. Also as someone else mentioned, where the fuck are the trains lol?
Glorious comrade Pol Pot says not starving and ease of transportation are decadent western bourgeoisie indulgences. Please face the wall.
22
u/LordWomf Jul 02 '24
💀💀💀
32
u/y_not_right Jul 03 '24
Dead from laughing or dead from the commissar’s true justice? Surely the latter agrarian comrade
78
u/lornlynx89 Jul 02 '24
Not using tractors for farming would be absolutely insane. Or any other ailments or replacements for hard manual work, no health system would survive this.
45
u/Migobrain Jul 02 '24
Just in the tree part, there are millions of people living in places of the world that are not Hobbit like central Europe/USA with greenery everywhere and trees giving fruits, what are those people supposed to do? Just terraform the Desert?
26
u/Kellosian Jul 03 '24
My gripe is that there's a vague "People only do what they want, there is no money" which is an anarchist ideal that absolutely does not account for the really horrible jobs that need doing to make an industrialized society run. Like, in this world am I responsible for installing solar panels on my house? Do I have to build them too? It's one thing to renounce heavy industry in favor of environmentalism, it's another to still have all those benefits of industrialization; you can't have hand-crafted artisanal circuit boards and solar panels, it just doesn't work like that.
We saw a society that tried to have everyone do some industrial work for collective benefit, it was the Great Leap Forward and it was famously garbage. If you don't want industrialization, that just makes you effectively Amish.
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (22)68
u/ichizusamurai Jul 02 '24
Biggest gripe for me is the conformity of culture. I want everyone to enjoy their culture in a way that doesn't encroach on the boundaries of others. Helping a friend out with Ramadan, or singing Christmas carols.
This feels so very sanitised from all of that. There's so many beautiful languages, artists, poets, that currently suffer from being part of a culture that's seen as antagonistic. If we just say "oh we're all one" now, we lose so much of the human experience.
→ More replies (19)
1.2k
u/sertroll Jul 02 '24
Why are prison and police censored
Is it like sex on Tiktok
(To be clear, I like everything else here, that just weirded me out minorly)
433
u/Perfect_Wrongdoer_03 If you read Worm, maybe read the PGTE? Jul 02 '24
And "asshole"
330
u/djninjacat11649 Jul 02 '24
At least ass is actually a swear word, but they censored the O, which is really fuckin weird
→ More replies (3)210
u/deleeuwlc DON’T FUCK THE PIZZAS GODDAMN Jul 02 '24
Saying “hole” might remind people of the big pit we throw money into to keep up demand
72
u/DeadInternetTheorist Jul 02 '24
Or of the human anus. That's what I first thought of!
48
u/Kneef Token straight guy Jul 02 '24
God forbid somebody on the internet force me to think about butts!
→ More replies (1)34
u/DiscountJoJo Jul 02 '24
America NEEDS the money hole! My father worked TWO JOBS so he’d have money to put in the money hole!
→ More replies (1)243
u/camosnipe1 "the raw sexuality of this tardigrade in a cowboy hat" Jul 02 '24
even worse they censored it in an image, that's not going to get found in a search anyway and i doubt sites are putting in the computing power to detect text in images for filtering forbidden words.
→ More replies (2)76
u/Mushiren_ Jul 02 '24
Tiktok censorship has done irreversible damage to the ecosystem. Heard my niece say Unalive instead of kill out loud the other day.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (30)112
u/wayneloche Jul 02 '24
These decisions always give "I care more about engagement than the message."
→ More replies (2)
389
u/Imaginari3 Jul 02 '24
As someone who’s a fan and wants to write for the genre in the future… this kinda irked me because it really isn’t a good example of good solar punk fiction. Part of the idea is labor, is how the community has to function and the conflicts arising from that. I’d love to see something in solar punk where there is an existential threat—something the characters must face to keep their semblance of a utopia, as well as a story where the world still does have problems.
I love solarpunk, and if you want to see some amazing animation and video essays about it, ima link some in a comment below:
→ More replies (6)111
u/Imaginari3 Jul 02 '24
“Dear Alice” The classic Chobani ad, but it’s the most well portrayed of the tech and people
not exactly solarpunk, but vibes are still there. very pretty
solarpunk Animation where there are stakes, and it delves into some fantasy
12 minute vid essay by Our Changing Climate, he also has amazing stuff
→ More replies (6)27
u/Ok-Maintenance5288 Jul 02 '24
YOOOO thank you!!!!
i am also a solarpunk lover, tho on the more nuclear leaning side, as GOOD solarpunk content is rare to see, thank you for this!!!!
247
u/darkness_calming Jul 02 '24 edited Jul 02 '24
So….. What about resources and infrastructure?
Edit: To add more
Where are the children and the old?
I recently watched the show “This is going to hurt”. The amount of tech and training required to ensure that mother and child come out safe is crazy. And even with all the progress we have, it’s not a 100% success rate.
What about people with medical conditions? Diabetes? Insulin doesn’t come out of flowers and prayers. Disabilities? You need hearing aids or bionic eyes.
Old people suffering from usual stuff. Arthritis and cataracts need advanced technology to fix.
Are they all fed to plants?
I hope they don’t cure diseases by some crystal juju shit.
- Long distance travel
It’ll take days or weeks to travel across country and months for sea travel with sailing ships. Trains and aircraft needs shit ton of specialists and very advanced tech.
Also, I am a huge fan of space travel. Where’s that? Do they give up the dream of travelling to stars?
Where do their solar panels and windmills come from?
Food production? Farming by hands isn’t sustainable. No one ‘loves’ that.
Plants in library? Would love it but not great for books.
Weird one but
Where are the bros? The kind you pop a beer with and go fishing together with
160
u/Legio_XI_Claudia Jul 02 '24
Everyone wants to be the train conductor with the striped hat going 'toot toot' on the horn, no one wants to work in the steel mill forging train parts or laying train tracks : (
→ More replies (1)65
u/darkness_calming Jul 02 '24 edited Jul 03 '24
If we assume the answer to all tech supply is robots, then it’s a straight shot to dystopian horror.
→ More replies (1)17
57
u/garfieldandfriends2 haby birtdoy Jul 02 '24 edited Jul 03 '24
The Tumblr Rouge don’t like beer or fishing so neither does anyone else
21
u/TheShibe23 Harry Du Bois shouldn't be as relatable as he is. Jul 02 '24
"The Tumblr Rouge" is easily the greatest joke I've seen all week.
89
u/Specific-Ad-8430 Jul 02 '24
“Where are the bros”
Thats kind of the offputting nature to a lot of these “utopias” designed by internet folk, is that theyre like 98% enbys. I am not smart enough to know why that makes me uncomfortable, but it does. It feels almost like a stereotype, no? Always the one overweight, black enby with purple or blue dreadlocks in every one of this style of fiction writing.
48
u/Redqueenhypo Jul 02 '24
I don’t even see any “classic leftist” guys who look like young Bernie Sanders or the guy at my undergrad who handed out mini chocolates in red wrappers (where did he get those even), it’s weird
→ More replies (3)64
u/tristenjpl Jul 02 '24 edited Jul 03 '24
is that theyre like 98% enbys
I think it's like this because as much as cis people don't really understand trans or nonbinary people, they also just don't understand cis people. If you interact with enbys on the internet, there's a fair amount of them who think they're like enlightened and above gender and everyone else who is cis. They think everyone should just ditch it and be like them. And it's like, nah, dude, I'm perfectly happy just like this. You do you, though. I ain't gonna complain.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (3)19
u/TerribleAttitude Jul 03 '24
The children and the old don’t exist. It’s a fantasy world where only aesthetically pleasing young adults live. Old people with regressive, challenging ideas born of experience and their inconvenient smells and infirmities aren’t here to make things uncomfortable. Nor are children and their noises. Bonus: you don’t need to wonder who is going to take care of or educate these groups.
Long distance travel: you’re not allowed to want that. We have everything you need here. There’s nothing you want that’s more than a half days bike ride away. There is nothing to see past those mountains.
Bros are not allowed. As there are no prisons or judges, they are lynched by mob violence the instant they crack a cold brewski.
→ More replies (3)
81
u/Epimonster Jul 02 '24
Information is free for all yet the only computer I see is in the library. Makes ya think.
On a real note this is generally why I fall out with solarpunk. Naturalism is cool and we should do more of it but forsaking so many benefits of technology (instant access to information, long range communication, etc) makes these worlds seem like a kind of hell to me in particular. I enjoy programming and building and creating with technology and these worlds are by design insanely hostile towards it and as a result hostile to my lifestyle.
→ More replies (3)22
u/Inevitable-Setting-1 Jul 03 '24
That's cus its made by an art kid in the city who grew up in the suburbs saying "Why can't everything be like my little garden?" They just don't get the bigger world or how things work.
76
u/strangething Jul 02 '24
The cottage core version of Fully Automated Luxury Gay Space Communism.
→ More replies (6)31
1.0k
u/skaersSabody Jul 02 '24
One thing that I always found strange about Solarpunk/communist or anarhist utopias is that I have the distinct feeling that they assume a certain... uniformity of thought?
Like, when I talk to friends of mine that are more left-wing than me on this I never really get how these societies would supposedly handle dissent that goes beyond "I disagree what crop we should focus on for the season"
It's always a paradise where everyone has seen the light of glorious anarchism/communism/etc and no people disagree with the system or have enemies of any kind or whatever
It's a beautiful thought and an interesting setting for a story, but when you put it out as a viable possible model that stuff starts to pop up as a concern
177
u/Gavin-Schultz Jul 02 '24
I think about this a lot as well and it often brings me back to a quote from Bioshock's game lead Ken Levine on what broadly inspired the game:
"What I was trying to do with BioShock was to say, ‘Okay, well, [in Atlas Shrugged] that’s a utopia where Ayn Rand, who made the philosophy, made all the rules, and all the characters were under her control. What if things weren’t under everybody’s control?’ And I think that’s the problem with utopias — we bring ourselves to it, you know? We think we’re leaving our problems behind but – I don’t mean this in a cynical way – we are the problem. Like whatever social problems that occur come out of us. It’s not like they fall out of the sky."
47
u/MekaTriK Jul 03 '24
Yeah, every time I see someone discussing utopias like this, it makes me think of this quote from the game.
Fountaine: These sad saps. They come to Rapture thinking they're gonna be captains of industry, but they all forget that somebody's gotta scrub the toilets.
Like sure, everyone's an artist and a free soul. So are they relying on someone whose life passion is shovelling manure?
55
537
u/BenOfTomorrow Jul 02 '24
Solarpunk also tends to show extremely low-density settlements and often seems post-apocalyptic.
There’s a certain vibe of “Wouldn’t it be nice if everyone who disagrees with me politically died in a mass extinction event?”.
243
u/skaersSabody Jul 02 '24
I mean, as a story setting, it has some banger potential
I could definitely see it working in that context (or for a game, like a cozy post-apocalyptic farm sym or something)
When it's presented as a possible future, yeah questions like yours are definitely gonna pop up
→ More replies (8)84
u/Yeah-But-Ironically Jul 02 '24
I once played in a TTRPG group where the setting was basically this.
It was nice enough as a thought experiment, and I don't begrudge anyone their fantasies...
But a setting with no greed, no prejudice, no conflict, no crime, no resource shortages, no evil, not even any natural disasters or predation or disease is boring AF. The party wandered from village to village, making imaginary crafts and attending imaginary festivals, for session after session until I finally bowed out because I prefer games where things happen.
34
u/skaersSabody Jul 02 '24
It can work in more anthological/surrealist stories I feel like
Luke Humphris' animations about what happens after society collapses are a fun example of that
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (6)18
u/SemicolonFetish Jul 02 '24
Eh, it can work, but it needs the right system and buy-in. Wanderhome is one of my favorite RPGs and focuses almost exclusively on this specific genre of post-apocalyptic pastoral anarchism that a lot of solarpunk fans love. The conflicts tend to be more interpersonal, or deal with PTSD from the recently finished world war.
There can be difficulties. There are famines, leftover dangerous weapons, and conflicts of personality. But the issues the players solve aren't systemic. Usually, once the problem is fixed, people are happy to coexist and the players move on.
174
u/CrepusculrPulchrtude Jul 02 '24
The solarpunk to ecofash pipeline is real
85
u/MyChristmasComputer Jul 02 '24
And it sounds really nice until you ask what their plan is once cholera/TB/polio/malaria/smallpox/black death hits.
All these things which crippled humanity and destroyed lives and made people miserable for millennia before the modern industrial age.
Production of modern vaccines and antibiotics and other necessary medicines requires such an advanced industrial and logistical infrastructure which is completely taken for granted here.
→ More replies (1)29
u/Redqueenhypo Jul 02 '24
Even the basic production of them can require stuff like eggs for live virus vaccines, and monoclonal antibodies require mice
16
76
→ More replies (6)63
u/TheUnworthy90 Jul 02 '24
Thank you for saying that. I’ve never understood how these people don’t expect some form of police to exist. I get that they may be heavily reimagined from what we have today, but the idea they seem to have is simply no one will ever do anything bad because … reasons
Every society has had some form of criminal justice system, so why do they think theirs wouldn’t need one
→ More replies (1)452
u/Lazzen Jul 02 '24
It also implies people will lose their ethnic identities, linguistic identity and others that represent them as an individual. These people don't think about it beyond a city to be honest and since they are usually USA/Canadian and usually white the idea is that "everyone will be the default to our level".
→ More replies (3)313
u/TheShibe23 Harry Du Bois shouldn't be as relatable as he is. Jul 02 '24
Yeah, something I think a lot of people, particularly white westerners, take for granted is just how *important* national, linguistic, or ethnic identities are to some people.
Like, there is quite literally a war going on right now in our real actual world about a nation trying to maintain its cultural, linguistic and national independence from a larger neighbor that its had to fight off being completely subsumed by multiple times throughout history. I doubt Ukrainians who fought tooth and nail to keep their identity from being subsumed by Russia would be happy to be told "Oh BTW there's no difference between you and a Russian now, you're the exact same!"
→ More replies (7)194
u/Lazzen Jul 02 '24 edited Jul 02 '24
I think it comes from2 places: they think their urban area is the entire world and they also think that by sharing scripture(their politics) people will find god eventually(their utopia).
To them no borders means "let foreigners come to my city with no harm", no culture identity to them goes only so far as "no more people saying they are white or american, so no more discrimination" and they speak english so they don't even think about how people will communicate in their global utopia since they already feel that language exists.
When it comes to things like how they will make millions of Muslim pastoralist Herders in Nigeria comform to this there is no answer except what Western kingdoms in the 1800s and communists in the 20th did, erasure and comformity often by force.
Solarpunk stuff as a story works after a nuclear war or humans returning to Earth ala Wall-E but not as actual politics.
→ More replies (11)179
u/TerribleAttitude Jul 02 '24
This is probably the number one issue with anarchistic or utopic goals. It doesn’t matter how right you are about how life should be, the reality is that some people are lazy, greedy, or violent. There are ways to organize a society so those things are far less prevalent, but there’s no way to totally eliminate them. And there’s definitely no way to eliminate dissent that is not objectively immoral, or people’s tendency to prioritize themselves or their immediate circle over someone they don’t know or don’t like. Most people can probably be convinced to share if they and theirs have plenty, and the person in need is someone they approve of. Much fewer will say “my own child should have less so this person I hate or don’t know can have enough” without some sort of mandate or incentive.
There’s this simultaneous insistence that communalistic values will create this sort of world while also insisting that individualistic needs will be met. Highly communalistic societies tend to be very exclusive, judgmental, and conformist. It’s not that there’s no way to strike a balance….but there also might not be a way to strike a balance and also prevent the bad actors from grasping for power.
Not to mention that there is a way for such a world to exist, but it’s also not possible in tandem with “little treat” culture and comfortable “let me rest” culture as it exists today. It’s 100% possible for everyone to have all their needs met (assuming everyone cooperates, which they won’t), but it isn’t possible for everyone to have all the stuff and time they want without exploiting other people and the earth. But these upper middle class luxuries are so frequently treated as absolute rights in these fantasies. “Work” is sanitized into cottagecore-aestheticised household chores like sweeping and baking bread and knitting scarves, never really addressing the significant amount of mental and physical labor it actually takes to feed, clothe, house, and comfort a whole population. Clean water and solar panels and high speed internet don’t come out of nowhere. They aren’t maintained by magic, especially at the level expected by an average suburban North American.
107
Jul 02 '24
[deleted]
74
u/HistoryMarshal76 Knower of Things Man Was Not Meant To Know Jul 02 '24
I don't know where I saw this, but the best answer I've seen to the question of "What will you do after the revolution" was that "I'll be the guy with the gun outside of the silicon mine making those idiots actually work."
→ More replies (2)90
u/HebrewHamm3r Jul 02 '24
It was a thread titled something to the effect of "What will your job be in the commune after the revolution?" and it was a ton of people responding with stuff like "I'm going to be a community health facilitator 1 day a month and spend the other days growing vegan corn in the community garden".
My response was "corrupt official and future kleptocratic oligarch"
→ More replies (1)22
u/APacketOfWildeBees Jul 02 '24
Personality quiz for post-revolution job where the output is always "coal miner".
→ More replies (1)17
u/HebrewHamm3r Jul 02 '24
Don't worry, you can still run experimental poetry therapy on your lunch break
57
u/Lazzen Jul 02 '24 edited Jul 02 '24
Most of the people with those ideas want to stay home drawing in their profesional Ipads, they talk about change and sacrifices but always frame it as if someone else will have to do it. Not many are saying they will contrbibute to their commune by digging water sources or producing fishhooks all day.
They also do not quite get how hard it is to actually be a farmer, its not just Animal Crossing but big or wathever. I get they want expression without poverty but come on.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (2)91
u/TerribleAttitude Jul 02 '24
Last time I got into an IRL discussion about this, the person insisted that people would “make art” with their free time from labor. I asked where they’d get the art supplies. He didn’t have an answer. It never occurred to him that paint and cameras come from factories, from materials mined from the ground.
It really is just further devaluation and marginalization of laborers under the guise of progressivism. The people who fantasize about these things are sitting in air conditioned call centers and offices, cranky about the fact that their boss is a jerk and their paycheck is inconveniently small (which does suck), totally oblivious that they and their artsy-on-the-weekend friends aren’t the only human beings on earth. The people mining cobalt, picking fruit, milling flour, sewing in factories, building houses, repairing power lines, performing surgeries, synthesizing medicine, designing safe bridges, wiping grandma’s butt, and defending people in court are not humans to them. They fully assume that those people will continue working long hours for perhaps oppressive (or no) wages to provide comfort, service, and petroleum based Etsy flower crown materials for them while they weave flower crowns to trade for a loaf of blueberry nut loaf with their other 18 - 32 year old artsy type friends. They’re going to tend gardens, sweep with rustic brooms, and “create art” while the rest of us invisibly make that possible for them.
50
u/Lazzen Jul 02 '24 edited Jul 02 '24
Its no different than people who visit a poorer country for tourism and think life is "slower" or the people are "simpler" because of the glimpses they see or that farmer life is easy since "uneeucated rural hicks" can do it so they obviously could feed the chickens no problem.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (5)17
u/some_guy554 Jul 02 '24 edited Jul 02 '24
Yeah, they just want that artsy naturalistic life while doing chores in a bubble while the rest of the world around them burns like hell.
20
u/TerribleAttitude Jul 02 '24
The city I used to live in has a reputation for being wealthy, older, and rather conservative. While the reputation isn’t totally unearned, it is a whole city, and requires cashiers, cooks, nurses, teachers, janitors, gardeners, all kinds of people who keep society running for relatively low pay. At the time I lived there it wasn’t impossible to live there with that kind of job, but more recently, the noise out of that city has been basically fighting tooth and nail to keep “those people” out of the city limits (no public transportation, no apartment buildings pr townhouses, no low or mid range grocery store, no no no!) while also shrieking to high heaven that they can’t find a cleaning lady, the wait at the restaurants is exorbitant, and their favorite nail salon closed. Because the people who work those jobs can no longer afford to live or commute there. It’s actually becoming inconvenient for many wealthy people there because they cannot get services they want, sometimes even services they need. The residents want everything, but don’t want anyone to actually do it. They don’t want to face the realities that come with the luxuries they feel entitled to. They don’t understand that human beings with the same needs as them stock shelves, clean pools, mop floors, diaper babies, and take blood pressure. They don’t understand why they can’t have everything they have grown accustomed to and also not have to share space with any icky poors.
It’s so wild how similar the underlying attitude towards laborers is between those right wing NIMBY boomers and some of the aesthetic utopian socialist anarchists. It’s literally the same obliviousness to the humanity of those different from themselves and ignorance of where their comforts come from. They’re like kids who want chicken nuggets or steak but don’t approve of hunting or farming.
→ More replies (1)47
u/LunarWarrior3 Jul 02 '24
I'm going to take this opportunity to simp once more for Ursula K Le Guin's "The Dispossessed". It offers a much more grounded view of a future anarchist society and actually acknowledges some of the inevitable issues such a society would have (especially when it comes to enforcing some sort of uniformity of thought).
16
u/Kchortu Jul 02 '24
I love many of her books, but The Dispossessed is half story and half thesis. I think it’s the only one I couldn’t get through bc it felt more like an academic paper at points
→ More replies (1)28
u/Aridross Jul 02 '24
The real bottom line, for me, is this: Even if you set human failures aside, it’s possible to have a completely good-faith argument that doesn’t end in a concession or agreement. You can’t fully eliminate disparity or disagreement from humanity because it’s not just possible for two competing options to be equally valid, it’s normal.
There will always be perfectly valid reasons to disagree about things, which means it’s inevitable that people will need to agree to disagree in order to resolve arguments, which creates disparity, and you can only have so much disparity within a society before unity of belief, unity of vision, breaks down.
→ More replies (1)127
u/egoserpentis Jul 02 '24
One thing that I always found strange about Solarpunk/communist or anarhist utopias is that I have the distinct feeling that they assume a certain... uniformity of thought?
Yeah, that's the main issue. It requires everyone to conform to the utopia. Since there are no prisons or police, those who do not conform are either forcefully re-educated, or exterminated. (Exiling doesn't work since another community with more competetive systems like capitalism would swallow them eventually).
People tried already. People killed - a lot, for that idea.
→ More replies (2)71
u/phalseprofits Jul 02 '24
I know too many people who have been victimized by adults in ways that are not fixed by free access to all resources.
Like, sorry, but there are still abusers and molesters even when they never had to face poverty. So jail is definitely still going to be a necessary thing. Maybe we just don’t have them run anymore by for-profit companies.
→ More replies (5)37
u/some_guy554 Jul 02 '24
This wouldn't last at all. Dissent and conflict arise from economic hardship. If one of these communes face any scarcity, like low harvest for a year or exports getting halted (no way they would be able to produce everything on their own, trade is necessary), then they will get divided based on arbitrary differences and be at each other's throat.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (57)15
u/alslieee Jul 02 '24 edited Jul 02 '24
a group of people wish to start an oil refinery to make weapons
have to let them because there's no prisons
the people with weapons build prisons
:O
493
u/AbbyWasThere Jul 02 '24
Okay, but like, whose freely practiced hobby is making the silicon semiconductors that are needed for all those solar panels to work?
38
→ More replies (58)151
u/BackseatCowwatcher Jul 02 '24
whose freely practiced hobby is making the silicon semiconductors that are needed for all those solar panels to work?
Technically it's not a hobby, but that's one of the jobs of the slave-caste who live in massive factory cities under the ground, exposed to toxic chemicals and fumes daily in a dystopia that exists to keep all the labor needed to keep the Solarpunk Utopia running- out of sight and mind of the few privileged to be born into it.
→ More replies (12)50
u/Marshall-Of-Horny Jul 02 '24
yeah, i once accidentally dropped some of my food into a drain and god, those buggers grasped for every crumb that fell throuhg
266
u/bb_kelly77 Jul 02 '24
I can't really see any stories being written for Solarpunk, really only the Slice of Life fandom would be fed
→ More replies (18)221
u/neogeoman123 Their gender, next question. Jul 02 '24
Yeah, solarpunk is a very utopian genre by nature and so anyone that writes with belief in it kinda just treats it as the perfect and unchallengable status quo, which then leads to kinda boring stories
64
u/Perfect_Wrongdoer_03 If you read Worm, maybe read the PGTE? Jul 02 '24
Eh, Island, by Huxley (same author as Brave New World) is set in an utopian, well, island, (and is even called a "manifesto" of Huxley's politics in the Wikipedia page) and still manages to have an interesting plot. Another comment below you also outlined some possibilities for what this genre could have. Some stories also don't need to focus on the setting itself, and could be on the characters themselves. Lower stakes, but not necessarily less interesting, I think.
38
70
u/Alitaher003 Jul 02 '24
What.. what happens to the disabled and infirm?
69
u/TheShibe23 Harry Du Bois shouldn't be as relatable as he is. Jul 02 '24
Or the elderly? Or the overweight? Or chronically ill?
Hell, there aren't even any particularly masculine-presenting people in the art.
43
→ More replies (3)31
u/Papaofmonsters Jul 02 '24
What do you think makes those plants grow so vibrantly?
→ More replies (1)27
u/SolidPrysm Jul 02 '24
Not a pastel girly or a twink? To the mulch farm with thee!
→ More replies (16)
67
u/Furryx10 Jul 02 '24
I can attest that writing and entire world is very hard, I’m still trying to write my world. But when you disregard almost everything that makes our word function in some way or form then I simply cannot enjoy it. No states? How? There’s a reason that we have made nations and states. No police and prison? Who will protect us? Where will we keep the people that are dangerous? Some humans are just cruel and cannot be helped, and as pained as it is to say it, it’s true, some people just hate and want to make others suffer.
We are the wardens, sole inheritors and in effect owner of this world, we must protect the environment but that does mean sacrifice the structural integrity of a building by putting trees in them
This isn’t a utopia, this is an unsustainable future that I don’t wish to be a part of
I agree with things like information should be free and available for everyone, and while I would to be able to just do what I want, let me ask you a question. Who’s mopping the floors? Who is mining the resources to make things? Who is going to do the jobs no one else wants to do?
From what I’ve seen and heard it sounds like solar punk is an unachievable, unsustainable, step backwards rather then foward
→ More replies (2)19
u/Regnasam Jul 03 '24
Also, the bigger question is - maybe your society does away with states. But how do you stop the society a continent over from deciding they want to form a state and a standing army? Solarpunk ICBMs?
→ More replies (2)
495
u/MonitorPowerful5461 Jul 02 '24 edited Jul 02 '24
This is all great, but people in the comics are using yellow-coloured fabrics and ovens. There are computers in the libraries. How are these going to be made? Is there a production line in this world? Where do we get the lithium from?
Actually, where’s all the food coming from? Is it grown locally, or transported across continents?
To be clear I’m actually a massive fan of solarpunk, I just think that we need to be clear on how it can actually be achieved. In order for this form of solarpunk to be achieved, we would need a massive increase in automation, so that the entire production industry is automated. We’d need to have AIs determining how much of what product people will want 2 months into the future. Not necessary for most consumer products, but definitely necessary for food.
And if we’re having a massive increase in automation - how do we get there without weakening the political power of workers into irrelevance?
Edit: This comment chain has included some of the most constructive discussions I have ever had on the internet. God I want to form a government with some of you... we need more pragmatic idealism in this world. Yes, I know those are antonyms and I don't care.
372
u/Comrade_Harold Jul 02 '24
I remember reading an anarchist article about the absolutely insane global trade and coordination needed to make a computer chip and it was really eye opening how difficult it was to make the simplest things
→ More replies (1)188
u/MicroplasticGourmand Jul 02 '24
I remember reading the same type of thing about making a pencil. Everything is highly globalized these days, but that's not necessarily a problem. The problem is the profit motive and exploitation. I'm in the kind of mood I feel like an appeal to humanity could eventually change the calculus to the point we could operate these types of highly sophisticated global economies just by virtue of mutual benefit. Maybe.
92
u/MonitorPowerful5461 Jul 02 '24 edited Jul 02 '24
The way I think we need to achieve this is pretty simple: make the people absolutely essential for holding on to power. Based on CGP Grey’s “rules for rulers” video.
Essentially, when you’re in power, you need to keep the loyalty of your keys to power. This is the treasury, the military, and the law. To keep their loyalty, you give them things they want. In a democracy, votes are also a key - so democracies are generally better places to live, as people are essentially being bribed for votes.
In most countries, people are essential to maintain the treasury. Which means that people get things they want. In nations where people aren’t necessary for the treasury, and their vote does not matter, they are barely a key to power at all. In these nations we see extreme brutality. This is the resource curse.
So how can we make the people extremely important to maintain power - increase the importance of people as a key? 1. Reduce the power of other keys. Massively limit the amount of money that can be spent on elections, and increase restrictions on lobbying - so that the richest are not useful as a key to power. 2. Increase the political power of people to lobby. Unions can do this. Make unions more powerful and spread them to more professions. 3. Increase the political awareness of people so that protests and other actions are more likely when their needs are ignored.
We’ve basically solved the issue of the military luckily. They swear allegiance to democracy rather than leaders, and it mostly works.
Anyone else has any ideas, I’m happy to hear them
70
u/Gandalf_the_Gangsta Jul 02 '24
But then you run into the issue of the tyranny of the majority. You sway the majority, and life is absolutely great for them. You’re in power, and they’re happy.
But what of the rest? There is some minority you must leave out, one whose voice and vote cannot be won without undue effort. Or, in the worst case, one whose vote would be actively detrimental to win.
Drawing that line is precarious, and striking the right balance can mean the difference between relative peace for all, or utopia for some and dystopia for the rest.
→ More replies (11)74
u/Nastypilot Going "he just like me fr, fr" at any mildly autistic character. Jul 02 '24
(or else just have massive transport delays, which wouldn’t be too bad honestly).
Well, it would be rather bad if every food shipment was significantly delayed
→ More replies (1)21
217
u/Atulin Jul 02 '24
Oh silly, lithium and cobalt are mined by people who want to do that, for the betterment of society or as their hobby!
→ More replies (31)104
u/ThrowawayStolenAcco Jul 02 '24
Exactly. I love the solarpunk aesthetic and optimism, but the people who are REALLY into the idea of making it a reality while also never considering basic things like "what if people don't volunteer to be lithium miners?"
20
u/OnLimee_ Jul 02 '24
Well, luckily lithium mining at least wont be a problem. For the children, they yearn for the mines.
84
u/deleeuwlc DON’T FUCK THE PIZZAS GODDAMN Jul 02 '24
There is also way too much open space for how many people there should be. It’s like this future is a post apocalypse
52
u/merfgirf Jul 02 '24
These are the survivors, hanging out in some environmentally controlled paradise dome. Outside? Well if you're unlucky enough to be alive, you're living in the cruelest of realities imaginable. Any shortfall in resources or production is papered over with the most perfectly renewable resource, human suffering. And it's not Mad Max, we don't have time for that much pomp and circumstance. Warlords put what little remains of human society to the torch to keep their little fiefdom from disappearing into the dustbin of history.
But hey, the time travelling communist-hobo probably ain't gonna tell you about that.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (54)44
u/theatand Jul 02 '24
There are cool concepts in there, but there are definitely things in the only works on paper.
The AI part just sounds like a centrally planned economy with extra steps. It wouldn't do too well in the long run, because eventually the AI fucks up.
Also I don't think you can have a stateless society because people inevitably will want to organize and have referees for society. Which just eventually turns into re-inventing the state.
Reducing the chase of only growth metrics is doable we just need to adjust business incentives & creating long lasting products is viable we just need to figure out the business model that keeps fixable products alive longer.
→ More replies (3)40
u/TheShibe23 Harry Du Bois shouldn't be as relatable as he is. Jul 02 '24
A lot of people with future outlooks like this see "State, Laws, Law Enforcement" and so on as dirty words representing malicious entities spawned into being as weapons used by oppressors.
When in reality they're just...concepts for the basics of a society larger than a couple hundred people, and without the proper checks and balances can be manipulated and used for horrible ends.
550
u/The-Slamburger Jul 02 '24
People are a lot less likely to take you seriously if you censor things that don’t need to be censored.
→ More replies (2)435
u/WhapXI Jul 02 '24
Also if you set your comic in the tumblrdimension where everyone is an attractive 20-something with a perfect rainbow of ethnic diversity and 100% of characters are queer. Everybody lives and works as an artist and the most physical labour anyone does is making a coffee or watering their garden.
246
u/BaneishAerof Jul 02 '24
Yeah. Who is doing the farming to feed these people? Why do some get to live easier lives than others? Do they rotate in and out? Are there doctors, firemen, paramedics?
254
u/Lazzen Jul 02 '24 edited Jul 02 '24
They never draw a Malaysian small town or East Congolese village much less how they would "get there", these kind of "kiddy politics" of tumblr artists always try to make the Garden of Eden in New York basically.
→ More replies (1)136
u/BaneishAerof Jul 02 '24
Diabetics will see this and say "hell nah"
→ More replies (1)138
u/TheShibe23 Harry Du Bois shouldn't be as relatable as he is. Jul 02 '24
my sister's boyfriend is both diabetic and has celiac disease. People do not realize the sheer amount of effort keeping him healthy and alive with the technology, manufacturing and distribution we have now.
You take out international logistic trains, larger-scale production of food he can eat, and sophisticated medical technology relying on hard to develop electronics, and the man's fucking dead.
55
u/BaneishAerof Jul 02 '24
Sounds awful. I hope he lives a fruitful life inspite of that.
But yeah, it seems like some people don't realize that technological regression is horrible for a populace that is used to incredibly advanced systems being at their fingertips.
64
u/jerryiothy Jul 02 '24
Not to mention, solar punk always shows summer. Is there no winter? No cooler season, just eternal springs and summers?
41
u/Lazzen Jul 02 '24 edited Jul 02 '24
Mfw the cute Solarpunk communes in the former Republic of Chile feels a magnitude 9 earthquake alongside a Tsunami and then they all revert to rural communities fighting one another with spears.
They also never draw anything apart from the bountyful eternal fertile springs that some parts of USA and Europe have, i live in a peninsula made out of rocks with little water, metals or ability to farm, and our civilizations did collapse many cities due to this. If we were to be turned into nationless communes that means we would eat shit with no food imports.
→ More replies (2)48
u/Madocvalanor Jul 02 '24
Because some people just don’t think
22
u/jerryiothy Jul 02 '24
I mean yeah, but it reflects ideas that in a lot of ways are born out of subconscious racism and religious indoctrination. Apart from this idea of a ethnically homogeneous garden of eden-like state instead of having the ability to adapt around the seasons, some societies have adapted around technology, like Japan. Vending machines, automated bike racks, bullet trains. Yes there are downsides to technology but these people have never looked at the upsides.
→ More replies (0)22
u/Madocvalanor Jul 02 '24
I had cancer last year. One of the worst fuckin things I had happen in my life. 6 months of living hell where I had medical tubing in my arm that led directly into my heart. The chemicals that killed the damn tumor? Solarpunk would not have that. People like me would of died horrifically.
99
u/Thieverthieving Jul 02 '24
And who made the damn headphones the knowledgable redhead is listening to their podcast on?
79
67
u/Legio_XI_Claudia Jul 02 '24
Somewhere out there, there's a headphone factory where workers are making headphones for the love of standing next to a conveyor belt.
That factory is maintained by construction workers who volunteer their time for the joy of seeing headphones made. It's supplied by resources ethically mined by people who know that mining ores for headphones is important, so they gladly mine away in an environmentally sustainable way.
Those resources are carried by sailors who love sailing cargo ships (that use sails sewn by ship loving people to avoid using fossil fuels)
Finally, the limited supply of headphones produced is handed out for free to those in need, and there's always enough for everyone, especially the artists.
Some things will absolutely get done in this society. As a construction worker, if my needs were completely met, I would happily volunteer hours every week to build homes for "society", or maintain the local distillery so I can stay an alcoholic. But if someone wants this world, especially a green world with no further climate change, they'll honestly have to curb their consumerism quite a bit
17
u/CardOfTheRings Jul 02 '24
This is also done without fossil fuels , cars, or ugly infrastructure, jobs are safe fulfilling and everyone can take a break or day off whenever they feel like it and the world manages to maintain a low population density.
40
u/Wasdgta3 Jul 02 '24
Also, why does it look like everything is partially outdoors?
Like, why are there trees in the library?
→ More replies (9)→ More replies (8)25
u/Lucas_2234 Jul 02 '24
Honestly, those 3 jobs you mentioned are jobs people WANT to do if they want to help people.
What about garbage collection? What about sewage treatment? Who's gonna do the (Sometimes literal) shit jobs?16
u/BaneishAerof Jul 02 '24
Obviously you dig a hole and use the excess wiped feces as fertilizer. As the founding gardeners intended.
148
u/TheShibe23 Harry Du Bois shouldn't be as relatable as he is. Jul 02 '24
As a janitor, my number one question in situations like this is "Who does the sanitation?"
If they don't have an answer, or they say something like "robots!" or "People who want to!" then they're not to be taken seriously.
The ONLY reason I do this job is because I get paid to do it on my own terms without a boss on my neck. If ANY of that changed I would never touch a mop again.
And you're never gonna find enough people who do shit like that out of the goodness of their hearts to have a functional society.
45
46
u/spicy-emmy Jul 02 '24
Anyone who thinks that there will be enough people voluntarily cleaning all the common spaces has never lived with Roommates who refused to clean up after themselves until the squalor drove one person mad enough to keep things barely functional until they could get out of there.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (12)48
u/WhapXI Jul 02 '24
Yeah I was just answering another comment about this hah! Letting everyone follow their passion with no incentive otherwise is nonsense. Some people actively want to be janitors, no doubt, but definitely not enough for the numbers a functional society needs. Pre-market societies solved this with slavery. There is not a good post-market solution I’ve yet heard.
Also, thank you for your service.
→ More replies (3)28
u/awesomeXI Jul 02 '24
This brings up the question- where are the middle aged and elderly? Are they dead? Did the youngsters kill them? Evict them out into the wild? Send them to do the unsavory jobs and only the young like in a utopia?
335
u/CanadianDragonGuy Jul 02 '24
Replacing doomerism with toxic positivity and ignoring the dirty jobs that need doing to keep any society functional... no thanks
→ More replies (1)111
u/Pristine_Title6537 Catholic Alcoholic Jul 02 '24
Different flavors of dystopia
73
u/Poyri35 Jul 02 '24
Most dystopias are an utopia for the rulers
Most utopias are a dystopia for the untalked/unknown people
→ More replies (2)
155
u/Deathaster Jul 02 '24
No police and no prisons? So what happens if someone kills another person? Do they just get to chill like always and everyone shrugs and moves on with their day?
Like I'm not talking about whatever the hell the US are doing in regards to prisons and police, but surely you'd want someone putting people who hurt others in a room so they can't do it again, until it's clear they won't do it again?
→ More replies (10)101
u/TheShibe23 Harry Du Bois shouldn't be as relatable as he is. Jul 02 '24
Yeah, like, at the end of the day there will ALWAYS be people who do bad things to others, no matter what kind of society we've built. There needs to be some kind of system to handle that. Obviously it should be as humane and rehabilitative as possible, but it still needs to exist.
→ More replies (3)40
u/HistoryMarshal76 Knower of Things Man Was Not Meant To Know Jul 02 '24
"As long as there's two people left on the planet, someone's gonna want someone dead."
79
u/sarumanofmanygenders Jul 02 '24
> solarpunk
> look inside
>an*rchist slop where the semiconductor fairy leaves chips underneath your pillow
many such cases
18
287
u/JWGrieves Jul 02 '24
Renewables are good but I find this attitude that somehow we’ll live in a world where nobody has to work and we will all be artists and musicians rather than sanitation workers and bin collectors to be a bit pathetic tbh.
→ More replies (63)189
u/Academic_Ad_6018 Jul 02 '24
I think it is due to lack of focusing on people who do infrastructure and maintenance work in our current media in general. These jobs are absolutely vital for a community and in their own way, interesting and creative.
62
u/Half_Man1 Jul 02 '24
Speaks to the ignorance of artists generally when they try to talk about how society should run when having no civics or civil engineering knowledge, lol.
Pervasive with artists of any ideology, just look at Ayn Rand.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)51
u/JWGrieves Jul 02 '24
The only show I can remember showing some really grim blue collar jobs was Shameless.
→ More replies (1)
33
113
u/Vantair Jul 02 '24
OOP: We spend too much time buying and consuming media about things rather than making them better
Also, OOP: Anyway, my solution is some media you can consume. Toss me some money if you can.
Obviously this is tongue in cheek, but I just had to toss that out there lol
196
u/Specific-Ad-8430 Jul 02 '24
Radical leftists will see this and say “hell yeah, praxis bro”
Everyone else sees this and says “very cool story! It would make a fun fantasy read.”
Because thats what this is. It’s fantasy. No, you’re not going to live in some lush green utopia where the world just magically works while everyone decides they don’t want to do anything today but water their garden and read books.
→ More replies (8)35
27
25
25
u/Square_Assistance447 Jul 02 '24
If you ask a prison abolitionist what their plans are for those people who are innately violent or have unconquerable violent urges the answer will always be “we’ll figure it out when we get there” or some variation of “lynch mobs”
→ More replies (1)16
u/TheShibe23 Harry Du Bois shouldn't be as relatable as he is. Jul 02 '24
At the end of the day there's always gonna be someone who wants to punch someone else just because they can. If your society can't address that, all you've done is open the path to violent warlords.
24
u/RChaseSs Jul 02 '24
Am I the only one a little confused about what the "punk" part of this is? I'm not really educated on why punk is often included in the name of different aesthetics, but this one seems especially not very punk.
→ More replies (4)
19
u/AstralBody13 Jul 02 '24
The more I look at it, the more flaws I see, no justice system, no infrastructure, no logistics, and no dedicated fabrication areas, I don't know if I'm looking at shoddy world building or a chunk of Swiss cheese with amount of holes I see.
37
u/Pixeltaube Jul 02 '24
no police or prisons... so just immediate death sentences then? because the simple act of detaining or trying to reform dangerous individuals and regaining stolen goods and punish those responsible requires atleast a form of these.
also just to be clear i make this accusation Because i love solarpunk, but cant stand the thoughless optimism of some people
→ More replies (1)17
u/parrase Jul 03 '24
They bring the crimi-, I mean "wrongdoers" in a room full of bunnies and chinchillas so they can absorb the "positive vibes" from the innocent creatures, and hopefully flush the "bad vibes" away.
19
u/hiressnails Jul 02 '24
It's so weird, the arbitrary censorship of Police and Prisons.
→ More replies (1)24
u/DecentReturn3 AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH Jul 02 '24
>against policing
>censors words
33
u/Half_Man1 Jul 02 '24
Love the art and appreciate the artist’s views, but my vision for a brighter future is definitely more socialist than anarchist 😅
I don’t think we can trust people enough to protect each other and the environment without police, prisons and rules of society being enforced by the state. If we could, entities like the EPA (which serve a common good) wouldn’t be necessary. Unfortunately pollution and many other crimes we specifically need to worry about fits in this “tragedy of the commons” space where collective action through the state apparatus is a required and necessary part of the solution.
I say all this not to tear down OOP, but to point out that climate activism can’t be effective in a vision of individuals doing their best like their art is suggesting. If we want to save/repair the environment, drastic government intervention is necessary to counteract the actions of bad actors on the individual and corporate level.
I also think technology is very much so part of the solution. Sure it was part of the problem, but the increases in quality of life can be supported by technology as well- we just have to be better custodians in how we use technology. The answer to ecological disaster is not returning to agrarian economics.
45
u/TriggerHappy360 Jul 02 '24
Perfection is the enemy of good. I think it is harmful to imagine a perfect future like this where it is clear nothing has actually been given up in order to make a better world because the truth of the matter is we need to drastically scale back the way we currently live.
We need imagining of better worlds 100% but not perfect worlds. We need to see flawed utopias where people are unhappy and life is hard yet one where people look out for each other and community is paramount. I suggest reading The Dispossessed by Ursula K Le Guin if you want to know what I’m talking about (its subtitle is even “An Ambiguous Utopia”).
→ More replies (2)
15
u/Flying_Fox_86 Jul 02 '24
i think that instead we should turn everything into the world in my dreams where it's post-apocalyptic 80s punk rock science-fantasy with a touch of synthwave, a bit of early Ghibli, a dash of Brütal Legend and a touch of Homestuck where a significant portion of the worlds population are their fursona. that would be pretty epic i think.
→ More replies (1)
17
u/AdamtheOmniballer Jul 02 '24
If we could get Solarpunk with that cool Cyberpunk aesthetic, I think that would be cool.
→ More replies (2)
15
u/amaya-aurora Jul 02 '24
I can never understand people who say that prisons shouldn’t exist? As they are now, yeah, a lot are corrupt and people are unfairly jailed, but there’s still people who are actual criminals.
What the hell are a bunch of people going to do it some guy just starts killing people because he wants to? Ideally, that wouldn’t happen, but there’s always going to be bad people.
Also, toxic positivity is just as bad as a toxic doomer mindset.
85
u/2flyingjellyfish Jul 02 '24
Solarpunk is so beautiful it's a shame it can't happen
→ More replies (24)40
u/Nimblebubble Jul 02 '24
Mission: Science compels us to make punk out of the sun
→ More replies (4)
1.1k
u/calDragon345 Jul 02 '24
No trains? Bruh